CATERING

Papa Joseph’s Restaurant and Catering is Long Island’s choice for great Italian food. Papa Joseph’s real Italian Catering is ready to handle your catering needs from 10 people to 500 people. We pride ourself in being one of Long Island’s best Italian Catering specialists. Choose from our extensive menu items like salads, pastas, chicken, fish and veal. Don’t forget about all of our wonderful desserts like cheesecakes, Cannoli and Tiramisu.

One of our specialties has always been serving large parties, our Italian heritage has taught us that people and food go together. We offer three options for large parties –

  1. Off-site catering – we can provide food for parties from 10 to 500, and can deliver / set up. We’ll work with you to design a menu to suit your event’s vision and budget.
  2. Banquets – our Grand Ballroom is designed for the perfect party. We can customize our menu to meet any guest’s needs, and best of all we do all the set up and clean up. Let us host your next event.
  3. Large Take Out orders – our extensive catering menus are available for take out in large portions. From half trays or full trays we have it all, sized for any crowd.

We hope you’ll try our specialties such as lasagna, meatballs and our cannoli dessert. Everything we offer is made fresh on the premises, using recipes passed down from generations of our family.

Appetizers

Baked Clams
Size
Half tray 6-10 people 50
Full tray 15-20 people 90

Mozzarella Sticks
Size
Half tray 6-10 people 40
Full tray 15-20 people 70

Mini Rice Balls
Size
Half tray 6-10 people 45
Full tray 15-20 people 85

Fresh Mozzarella
With tomato & basil
Size
Half tray 6-10 people 45
Full tray 15-20 people 90

Cold Antipasto
Size
Half tray 6-10 people 40
Full tray 15-20 people 75

Garden Salad
Size
Half tray 6-10 people 25
Full tray 15-20 people 45

Greek Salad
Size
Half tray 6-10 people 35
Full tray 15-20 people 60

Mediterranean Salad
Size
Half tray 6-10 people 35
Full tray 15-20 people 60

Caesar Salad
Size
Half tray 6-10 people 35
Full tray 15-20 people 60

Mini Crab Cakes
Size
Half tray 6-10 people 100
Full tray 15-20 people 195

Broccoli Rabe
Size
Half tray 6-10 people 50
Full tray 15-20 people 90

Stuffed Mushroom
Primavera
Size
Half tray 6-10 people 45
Full tray 15-20 people 85

Frutti di Mare
Cold seafood salad
Size
Half tray 6-10 people 75
Full tray 15-20 people 120

French Fries
Size
Half tray 6-10 people 25
Full tray 15-20 people 50

Chicken Wings (12)
Mild, medium or hot
Size
Half tray 6-10 people 8.95
Full tray 15-20 people n/a

Garlic Knots (12)
Size
Half tray 6-10 people 3
Full tray 15-20 people n/a

Hot Trays

Pasta

Tomato Sauce
Size
Half tray 6-10 people
Full tray 15-20 people

Pasta
Penne 25 Spaghetti 40

Meat Sauce
Size
Half tray 6-10 people
Full tray 15-20 people

Pasta
Penne 35 Spaghetti 65

Marinara Sauce
Size
Half tray 6-10 people
Full tray 15-20 people

Pasta
Penne 25 Spaghetti 40

Olive Oil & Garlic
Size
Half tray 6-10 people
Full tray 15-20 people

Pasta
Penne 25 Spaghetti 40

Baked‏

Stuffed Shells
Size
Half tray 6-10 people 30
Full tray 15-20 people 60

Ravioli
Cheese
Size
Half tray 6-10 people 30
Full tray 15-20 people 60

Ravioli
Cheese parmigiana
Size
Half tray 6-10 people 35
Full tray 15-20 people 65

Ravioli with Meat Sauce
Size
Half tray 6-10 people 45
Full tray 15-20 people 80

Manicotti
Size
Half tray 6-10 people 35
Full tray 15-20 people 60

Lasagna
Size
Half tray 6-10 people 45
Full tray 15-20 people 80

Baked Penne
Size
Half tray 6-10 people 35
Full tray 15-20 people 65

Veal

Veal Marsala
Size
Half tray 6-10 people 65
Full tray 15-20 people 130

Veal Francese
Size
Half tray 6-10 people 65
Full tray 15-20 people 130

Veal Parmigiana
Size
Half tray 6-10 people 65
Full tray 15-20 people 130

Veal Milanese
Size
Half tray 6-10 people 65
Full tray 15-20 people 130

Veal Rollatini
Size
Half tray 6-10 people 65
Full tray 15-20 people 130

Veal Pizzaiola
Size
Half tray 6-10 people 65
Full tray 15-20 people 130

Veal Saltimbocca
Size
Half tray 6-10 people 65
Full tray 15-20 people 130

Veal Piccata
Size
Half tray 6-10 people 65
Full tray 15-20 people 130

Chicken

Chicken Cacciatore
Size
Half tray 6-10 people 55
Full tray 15-20 people 95

Chicken Rollatini
Size
Half tray 6-10 people 55
Full tray 15-20 people 95

Chicken Parmigiana
Size
Half tray 6-10 people 50
Full tray 15-20 people 90

Chicken Francese
Size
Half tray 6-10 people 50
Full tray 15-20 people 90

Chicken Marsala
Size
Half tray 6-10 people 50
Full tray 15-20 people 90

Chicken Siciliana
Size
Half tray 6-10 people 50
Full tray 15-20 people 90

Chicken Fingers & Fries
Size
Half tray 6-10 people 35
Full tray 15-20 people 65

Chicken Pizzaiola
Size
Half tray 6-10 people 55
Full tray 15-20 people 95

Fish

Spaghetti
Sauce
Red clam sauce or White clam sauce
Size
Half tray 6-10 people 55
Full tray 15-20 people 95

Shrimp Scampi
Size
Half tray 6-10 people 65
Full tray 15-20 people 130

Shrimp Marinara
With mussels
Size
Half tray 6-10 people 65
Full tray 15-20 people 130

Shrimp Fra Diavolo
With mussels
Size
Half tray 6-10 people 65
Full tray 15-20 people 130

Shrimp Parmigiana
Size
Half tray 6-10 people 65
Full tray 15-20 people 130

Mussels Vino Biancho
Size
Half tray 6-10 people 30
Full tray 15-20 people 55

Mussels Marinara
Size
Half tray 6-10 people 30
Full tray 15-20 people 55

Mussels Fra Diavolo
Size
Half tray 6-10 people 30
Full tray 15-20 people 55

Scungilli Fra Diavolo
Size
Half tray 6-10 people 55
Full tray 15-20 people 95

Calamari Fra Diavolo
Size
Half tray 6-10 people 55
Full tray 15-20 people 95

Fried Calamari
Size
Half tray 6-10 people 55
Full tray 15-20 people 95

Specialty Trays

Carbonara Spaghetti
Size
Half tray 6-10 people 45
Full tray 15-20 people 80

Fettucine Alfredo
Size
Half tray 6-10 people 40
Full tray 15-20 people 70

Tortellini Alfredo Cheese
Size
Half tray 6-10 people 40
Full tray 15-20 people 75

Rigatoni Puttanesca
Size
Half tray 6-10 people 35
Full tray 15-20 people 70

Penne alla Vodka
Size
Half tray 6-10 people 40
Full tray 15-20 people 75

Baked Penne Siciliana
With eggplant
Size
Half tray 6-10 people 40
Full tray 15-20 people 65

Eggplant Parmigiana
Size
Half tray 6-10 people 40
Full tray 15-20 people 70

Egggplant Rollatini
Size
Half tray 6-10 people 45
Full tray 15-20 people 75

Sausage & Green Peppers
Size
Half tray 6-10 people 35
Full tray 15-20 people 60

Sausage & Green Peppers
Size
Half tray 6-10 people 35
Full tray 15-20 people 60

Penne with Broccoli
Size
Half tray 6-10 people 30
Full tray 15-20 people 55

Garlic & Oil Penne Primavera
Size
Half tray 6-10 people 35
Full tray 15-20 people 65

White or Red Orecchiette alla Barese
Sauce
White or Red
Size
Half tray 6-10 people
Full tray 15-20 people

Red or White Spaghetti Chi Sardi
Sauce
Red or White
Size
Half tray 6-10 people 45
Full tray 15-20 people 80

Rigatoni all Amatriciana
Size
Half tray 6-10 people 40
Full tray 15-20 people 80

Meatballs in a Homemade Tomato Sauce (20)
Size
Half tray 6-10 people 35
Full tray 15-20 people n/a

Sausage in a Homemade Tomato Sauce (20)
Size
Half tray 6-10 people 35
Full tray 15-20 people n/a